March 16, 2022
March 16, 2022
State Rundown 3/16: The Scramble to Curb Rising Gas Prices is On
Rising gas prices have lawmakers around the country searching for ways to ease the pressure on consumers and almost half the states are considering reducing or temporarily repealing their gas tax. Another idea taking hold, however, is the gas tax holiday, and this week, ITEP’s Carl Davis explains why these holidays aren’t worth celebrating. Elsewhere, Republicans in Arizona look to be gearing up for a special session with the goal of bypassing a voter referendum that will determine the fate of a recently approved and highly regressive tax cut plan. In South Carolina, the Senate passed its own $2 billion tax cut that features a reduction to the top marginal rate and differs slightly from the House plan, as it also includes $100 rebate checks. And while Georgia politicians are currently focused on a proposed bill that would suspend the gas tax, ITEP still has its eye on the regressive tax cut plans in the House and Senate and how both chambers plan on reconciling the bills.
Major State Tax Proposals and Developments
- A special session could be called soon in ARIZONA, as Republican lawmakers aim to sidestep a voter-led veto referendum that is blocking the almost $2 billion income tax cut plan they passed in 2021 from going into effect. The goal would be to repeal the plan from last year and replace it with a new tax cut bill, effectively nullifying the need for voters to approve or reject the tax cut. The calls for a special session have picked up after a Superior Court judge struck down Proposition 208, a ballot measure that would have increased taxes on the wealthy and used the revenue to fund education. – MARCO GUZMAN
- All eyes in GEORGIA seem to be on a proposed gas tax suspension bill, but a more costly and permanent issue is the House’s recently approved flat 5.25 percent income tax bill that would eliminate most itemized deductions, raise the amount of income exempt from taxation, and cost over $1 billion annually, primarily benefiting the wealthy. It is still unclear how the House and Senate will reconcile their tax cut plans. – KAMOLIKA DAS
- The MISSISSIPPI Senate passed their amended version of the House proposal to reduce the income tax. Compared to the Senate’s last version, the plan would reduce the top income tax rate to 4.6 percent and include a 6-month suspension of the gas tax. The updated House plan still eliminates the state’s income tax, although implementing a slower phaseout via exemptions. The plan also includes a reduction in the state’s tax on groceries but much more slowly by just 0.25 percent a year, hitting 4 percent in 2034. The House plan no longer includes cutting car tag fees or increasing the sales tax. Both plans are far more costly than their respective previous iterations and are heavily tilted towards the top. House and Senate leaders are expected to hold final negotiations later this month. – KAMOLIKA DAS
- Senators in SOUTH CAROLINA have unanimously passed a $2 billion tax cut bill that would reduce the state’s top income tax rate from 7 to 5.7 percent and would cut the state’s manufacturing property tax from 9 to 6 percent. The bill also includes $100 minimum rebate checks for tax filers. The House unanimously passed a similar plan that did not include rebate checks. – NEVA BUTKUS
Governors’ Annual Addresses and State of State Speeches
- LOUISIANA John Bel Edwards announced that his budget will include teacher pay raises, higher education faculty pay raises, money for early childhood education and pay raises for law enforcement and first responders in his State of the State address.
- The ALABAMA Senate approved a bill that would eliminate the state’s business privilege tax, the minimum tax levied on some corporations and business trusts, at a cost of $23 million per year. The legislature is also likely to pass tax breaks for retirees who rely on defined contribution plans and a standard deduction increase. Five bills have been introduced to cut the grocery tax but these proposals have not yet advanced.
- FLORIDA lawmakers passed a budget that included two new tax holidays this year – the Skilled Worker Tools sales tax holiday and a month-long gas tax holiday in October. Fortunately, a corporate tax break bill that would have cost the state $3.5 billion over the next few years did not ultimately pass.
- Advocates in ILLINOIS are pushing for an expansion to the state earned income tax credit and the creation of a state child tax credit.
- The KANSAS House Tax committee advanced a bill that would reduce the state’s general sales tax to 6.3 percent and sales tax on groceries to 3.5 percent. Kansas currently has a sales tax of 6.5 percent; groceries are taxed at the full rate.
- A state senator in LOUISIANA is hoping to make temporary reforms to the state’s Industrial Tax Exemption Program – ironically sharing the same acronym as ITEP – permanent. Before Gov. John Bel Edwards took office, an unelected state board could rubber stamp local property tax exemptions for manufacturers without approval from the municipalities losing the revenue.
- MARYLAND Larry Hogan and legislative leaders announced a month-long gas tax suspension, costing the state nearly $94 million, but the measure is unlikely to significantly benefit Marylanders living paycheck to paycheck.
- MICHIGAN Republicans have sent their $2.5 billion tax cut plan to Gov. Gretchen Whitmer who plans to veto the bill. The plan cuts the state’s flat income tax rate from 4.25 to 3.9 percent and adds a large additional exemption for retirement income.
- Sales and gaming tax initiatives to improve education funding will not appear on NEVADA ballots this November after all, following a judge’s decision on the matter. The measures were originally created by the Clark County Education Association, which attempted to withdraw them after reaching a deal to raise some of the intended revenue legislatively, but there was disagreement over whether the Secretary of State could actually legally remove them from the ballot.
- NEW HAMPSHIRE Chris Sununu has proposed temporarily suspending the gas tax as well as the rooms and meals tax.
- A NEW JERSEY bill would cut the gas tax by half if the average price of a gallon of unleaded regular reaches $4.51 and completely suspend it if it tops $5.50.
- NEW YORK lawmakers are seeking EITC improvements to bring the state in line with best practices recently enacted in other states to extend the credit to more workers without children and workers without Social Security numbers.
- The House Majority Floor Leader Jon Echols in OKLAHOMA proposed a bill that would create a 100% tax credit for parents’ donations to their child’s schoolteacher of up to $1,000. The bill would set up an anonymous system where parents could write off their donations. The credit would be capped at $5 million annually. The bill passed the House.
- OREGON cannabis revenues continue to come in strong and the state is considering expanding cities’ ability to raise local rates.
- Some PENNSYLVANIA lawmakers have also introduced legislation to cut the gas tax, using federal funds to replace lost revenue.
- TENNESSEE Democratic lawmakers also proposed suspending the gas tax for 90 days.
- VIRGINIA lawmakers ended their regular legislative session without passing their two-year budget and numerous other bills. The House and Senate have not come to an agreement on tax cuts so Gov. Glenn Youngkin is expected to call a special session.
- VIRGINIA Glenn Youngkin also announced plans to introduce emergency legislation to suspend state gas taxes for three months but a similar proposal was rejected by legislators earlier this year.
- WASHINGTON’s legislative session has ended without major tax action. The state’s new payroll tax for long-term care was delayed a year earlier in the session, a film tax subsidy was increased, and lawmakers rejected a misguided sales tax holiday proposal in the final week.
- The WEST VIRGINIA General Assembly passed a state budget without the House’s proposed 10 percent income tax cut. However, part of the state surplus may be used for future tax cuts. In other news, lawmakers advanced a proposal to eliminate the soda tax.
What We’re Reading
- A revealing study released last month and gaining more attention recently found that California’s Proposition 13—long known to create inequitable gaps between established homeowners and newer homebuyers—also disproportionately benefits white and wealthy households compared to homeowners of color and low-income households. This is primarily because white owners’ homes appreciate in value faster, quickly driving up their benefit from Proposition 13’s valuation freeze, while homeowners of color see their home values and tax savings grow much more slowly.
- A recent article in Law & Society Review argues that some of the ways we think and talk about taxes, particularly centering “taxpayers,” lend themselves to what the author refers to as “fiscalized racism,” wherein “ostensibly fiscal concerns are imbricated with white political entitlement that erodes Indigenous legal and political sovereignty.”
- Whitney Tucker and Coty Novak at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities examine the relationship between state tax cuts and voting restrictions that are worsening inequalities and how the two are rooted in our nation’s history.
- The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities shared an insightful blog post highlighting the impact the expanded Child Tax Credit and Earned Income Tax Credit are having on reducing poverty in Puerto Rico.
If you like what you are seeing in the Rundown (or even if you don’t) please send any feedback or tips for future posts to Aidan Davis at [email protected]. Click here to sign up to receive the Rundown via email.