State and local taxes exist primarily to fund schools, roads, health care, and other services needed for communities to thrive. There are multiple ways to achieve this goal, so it can be helpful to evaluate different options based on a few core principles.
State and local tax codes have the potential to either narrow or widen racial inequality created by historical and current injustices in public policy and in broader society. In general, tax codes that are more progressive across the economic spectrum do more to narrow racial inequality, while regressive tax policies exacerbate it.
Most states use the federal tax code as a starting point for their calculations of state personal income taxes, corporate income taxes, and estate taxes. Changes to the federal code and federal tax administration have the potential to affect state tax systems enormously, but to some extent states can pick and choose which of those federal changes to accept.
A Tax and Expenditure Limit (TEL) is a formula written into state law or into a state constitution that constrains government revenue and spending. These measures can undermine governmental accountability, degrade essential public services like health care and education, and create inequitable tax burdens.
Tens of thousands of local governments in the United States, from big cities like Los Angeles and New York to rural counties, school districts, and small towns, operate schools, roads, parks, public safety, and other services. To pay for it, they collect roughly $1 trillion in taxes annually and receive another $800 billion in grants from states. But states, not just localities, set many of the rules for local taxes, and sometimes use that authority to undermine local democracy.
Tax policy is an important economic tool, but claims that tax changes will affect a state’s economy are often overstated. Such overstated claims are particularly common in discussions of taxes on wealthy individuals and profitable corporations, so careful assessment of such claims is an important part of shaping adequate and equitable revenue streams.